You are here

Park Ranger Who "Tased" Native American Visitor Cleared Of Wrongdoing

Share

An internal investigation into a ranger who "tased" a Native American visitor at Petroglyph National Monument determined that he acted appropriately. The individual who was tased was cited for going off trail, providing false information, and failing to obey the ranger.

“The National Park Service remains committed to respecting the rights and dignity of every individual. This incident provided a learning experience for us to build on how we incorporate Tribal and Pueblo perspectives in our everyday work,” said National Park Service Regional Director Mike Reynolds in a statement issued Friday. “In the months ahead, we will be working with the Pueblo and Tribal communities to develop ways to better coordinate use of the area for ceremonial and religious purposes.” 

The incident occurred December 27 when the unidentified ranger approached the man and his female companion to ask them to return to the marked trail they had left because they were "off trail on rocks containing petroglyphs," according to the Park Service.

"This is not a big deal, this is a simple warning," said the ranger, whose body camera captured the interaction.

While the ranger explained that it was his job to protect the monument because it is considered sacred to tribes, and noted that there had been past issues with graffiti, the man responded that, "We don't do that."

The ranger told the couple that he just needed their names so he could check to see if they previously had been warned about going off trail in the monument, but the man said he wasn't going to provide that information. His companion did provide their names, which the National Park Service later said were fictitious.

"You don't need my identification, sir," the man told the ranger. "Native Americans and the goverment and the law don't mesh well, you know that."

The man, who later identified himself to news reporters as Darrell House, walked away while the ranger contacted the monument's dispatch center to run a check on the names he was given. When the ranger caught up to the couple, who were now back on a trail, the man again refused to answer the ranger's questions.

"So, let me get this straight, you'd like to escalate this contact by refusing to identify yourself, and then in which case you're going to be detained until I can ID you?" the ranger asked. 

As the man walked away, the ranger followed him, asking that he stop or he risked being "tased." The ranger then asked the man to give his small dog to his companion. 

"My dog ain't going anywhere," replied the man, who had picked up the small dog.

"Sir, please give her the dog," the ranger said.

"My dog ain't going anywhere," the man again replied.

"OK, here's what I need you to do. Stop right now sir. Stop walking. Stop walking or you may be tased. Stop walking," the ranger said.

While the man stood holding his dog, the ranger could be seen aiming his Taser at the man. The man refused to give his companion the dog and started yelling "help," at which point the ranger shot him with the stun gun.

The Park Service investigation "determined that the law enforcement ranger's actions were consistent with agency policy and appropriate given the totality of the circumstances, including policy to preserve the significant cultural resources of the petroglyphs," the statement issued Friday said. Additionally, it noted that the Park Service "has worked to renew its commitment to Tribal engagement and is drawing on community partnerships to strengthen collaboration and cultural awareness within and outside of the monument."

With input from local Pueblos and Tribes, the Park Service is working to implement a plan to strengthen protection of the sensitive cultural resources found in the park through a designated trail system.

Park staff also recently met with representatives from the Ancestral Lands Conservation Corps, a long-term partner of the park, to identify ways to improve incorporation of Pueblo and Tribal work crews, youth and families into park programming and projects.

The National Park Service has also sought cultural awareness training for its employees and expert guidance from the Indian Pueblo Cultural Center and will continue to pursue future opportunities with the City of Albuquerque’s Open Space Division and Office of Diversity and Inclusion.  

Comments

ecbuck:
Yes really.  The report is unequivocable in its conclusion that the park was not cleared for the purpose of a photo opportunity.  If the Diocese had a problem with Trump being on the property they have full recourse through the courts.  I haven't seen any suit filed.

I wasn't referring to the park being cleared.  I  believe that USPP cleared it because they had already planned to install the fence.  But then again I also believe the quote that expressed displeasure that it might be perceived as being cleared to allow Trump through.

As far as suing the federal government goes, it's not really all that easy unless someone has died.  I have yet to hear anything that justifies the use of force against people who were legally on church property.  Only a lawsuit could prove that it was unjustified?  It was kind of hard to stay there after getting gassed .  But if somehow the Pastor could have stayed there and was adamant that the group of US government officials (including Trump) were not allowed to be on church property (which they've hinted) would you agree that Trump trespassed?  Or at least admit that he wasn't welcome?  Exactly what do you think justified police ejecting people from church property so that Trump could get his photo op?  I understand that police could legally expel people from Lafayette Park due to a planned clearance, although it doesn't sound as if most people heard an announcement, including those who got hit by USPP.  But on church property is a whole new thing, and I don't think you would support such a violation of private property rights unless it was in the service of Trump.

 

https://www.episcopalnewsservice.org/2020/06/04/episcopal-priest-seminar...

"We were kneeling on the corner when, all of a sudden, the police line pushed forward. And there was screaming, and then there was a flash grenade. There were loud, echoing reverberations off the building. And then what I witnessed was a yellow-gray fog cloud in the air as people were going back towards the patio of St John's, and immediately, pain in my eyes, burning. Immediate pain in my nose. Immediate coughing and throat pain." The painful inflammation in Domenick's eyes was only relieved later when she was given milk of magnesia to wash out her eyes.

Meanwhile, Gerbasi was on the church's patio, tending to another protester.

"I was rinsing someone's eyes, and the man in front of me said that he thought he had been hit by rubber bullets. And when I looked up at him, I saw all these marks on his shirt. And then I looked up over his shoulder, and I saw the row of police coming onto St. John's Lafayette Square patio. I was incredulous."

 

https://www.cnn.com/videos/us/2020/06/02/donald-trump-gini-gerbasi-st-jo...

 


Ok, this conversation has really strayed from the specific story. We're closing it to new comments.


The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.