You are here

More Fallout From Grand Canyon Sexual Harassment Complaints

Share

Grand Canyon National Park Superintendent Dave Uberuaga, acting in the wake of a tide of sexual harassment complaints, has dismantled the River District Office where the grievances arose.

The superintendent, in an email to all his employees, wrote that he takes "full responsibility for the situation the park finds itself in and I acknowledge and accept that over time, a culture was tolerated that allowed sexual harassment and created a hostile work environment."

That email, sent Wednesday, came a day after National Park Service Director Jon Jarvis sent an email to all Park Service employees stating that "no employee has the right or the power by nature of their position to inflict their will or to subject co-workers, regardless of their status, to abuse."

The emails stemmed from an Interior Department investigative report that found that for 15 years life deep in the Inner Gorge of Grand Canyon National Park at times reflected rowdy, sexually charged scenes from a frat party for some Park Service employees, with male employees pawing and propositioning female workers, some of who at times exhibited their own risqué behavior. 

The investigation by the Interior Department's Office of Inspector General generated a tawdry list of inappropriate behavior, from male employees taking photographs up under a female co-worker's dress and groping female workers to women dancing provocatively and bringing a drinking straw "shaped like a penis and testicles" to river parties. The incidents, the September 2014 letter to Secretary Jewell charged, "demonstrated evidence of 'discrimination, retaliation, and a sexually hostile work environment.'"

The report, released in January, also stated that Park Service managers, from Superintendent Uberuaga to Intermountain Regional Director Sue Masica, had been aware of the allegations prior to 2014 and yet relatively little was done to change the river culture.

According to the 13-page OIG report, Superintendent Uberuaga, when provided with the Equal Employment Opportunity report from a 2013 investigation, "did not provide the report to HR or GRCA managers, and did not request HR personnel’s opinions about potential disciplinary action against the employees named in the report. No one was disciplined for failing to properly respond to the allegations, he said, because the EEO report indicated that these failures were 'not actionable.'”

"As the superintendent of Grand Canyon National Park, I have the responsibility to take corrective action which includes rebuilding trust and credibility. To do so, I must work to ensure that the same or similar events do not occur in the future; and I must take decisive actions that demonstrate that we take such matters outlined in the OIG report seriously," Superintendent Uberuaga wrote to his staff. "As a result of considerable review of the facts and reflections of my own sense of right and wrong, I have made the decision to abolish the River District of the park and to create an opportunity for a fresh start and a total review of our mission and responsibilities on the river.

"As part of the OIG response plan, the Deputy Regional Director will engage an external, multi-disciplinary team to conduct a comprehensive top-to-bottom examination of the river operations. The findings and recommendations from this report will inform how the park will carry out its mission along the river. In the coming weeks and months we will develop the details of implementation."

In his email to the entire Park Service family, Director Jarvis acknowledged that across the system many employees "have expressed shock and dismay that the serious behavior and practices described has occurred for so long."

While he added that personnel matters and pending Equal Employment Opportunity cases require confidentiality, he wanted to "assure you that we are taking active steps in response to this situation."

"... Certainly, this type of behavior is unlawful," he wrote. "While policy, rules and regulations exist to protect all of us, treating people with respect is foundational to our culture.  The National Park Service is committed to ensuring a work environment that is free of threatening, hostile or demeaning behavior.

"The culture in this arena is of deep concern for me. I am asking every one of you to work to change this. Take it upon yourself to initiate the dialogue, as we all have the responsibility to bring these issues to the forefront. If you have concerns, discuss them first with your supervisor," the email continued. "Leadership, regardless of position, matters. If the response is inadequate, seek out a supervisor in a different discipline. Initiate the dialogue, talk to a supervisor, and if a response or mediation does not occur, seek out your local equal opportunity counselor or contact.

"Together we must create a culture of acceptance, which treats every individual with respect and provides employees with a safe and secure work environment. You deserve nothing less."

Comments

No Rick, no one is minimizing anything - except maybe you but certainly not me.  I am pointing out that it is not a male vs female issue, its not a racial issue, its not a conservative vs liberal issue.  It is an issue of what is approriate and what is not.  There was inappropriate behavior across the board.  I don't have to "spread it around to everyone", they did that on their own. 

And so funny, Lee's paddling, which he so admires, is exactly the kind of thing that wouldn't be accepted under today's political correctness.


No, ec, it's not "political correctness" that prevents a swat or two to the behind to enlighten the head.  It's part of the Great American Entitlement Mentality.  "My kid is entitled to do whatever he or she wants to do, when they want, it and how they want it without fear of accountability."  It goes right along with the Conservative Entitlement Mentality which says, "I want services of all kinds, but don't ask me to pay for them."  Or the Progressive Entitlement Mentality which states, "I want services, too.  But I'm willing to pay my fair share for them."

Political Correctness all depends upon your point of view.

But regardless, what happened at Grand Canyon (and on college campuses, fire stations, police stations, businesses of all kinds and a whole bunch of other examples) is completely disgusting regardless of gender.

 


"My kid is entitled to do whatever he or she wants to do, when they want, it and how they want it without fear of accountability." 

Then why aren't you giving he/she a good swat.  Because if you do, the PC crowd will be reporting you to the authorities.  No doubt "entitlement" driven by the everything should be free left is a problem but it is the PC that is preventing the cure.

As to conservative entitlement.   Please give me an example of a conservative making that argument.    As to Progressive entitlement, you misstated their argument.  They want services but they want "the rich" to pay for them.  

But at least you get that inappropriate behavior isn't limited to just one gender.


VGina Wolfe * in a few seconds

I have over 250 hours of volunteer time in the Park. I have taken 5 river trips with 3 out of 4 of these boatmen. Frankly, it is true they are heralded as rock stars on the river. They know what they are doing and their confidence drew women to them. They were not only confident but were strong, healthy, knowledgeable, kept us safe from hazards and cooked for us.  I agree that there were some shinanigans going on down there however the solicitation was being done by both the men and the women.  I am witness to it.  I find it shameful that these women equate their grievances to the seriousness of real women who have been truly raped and abused. Lets remember the reason why this has all come about...because 2 NPS women employees were disciplined by the NPS for sexual misconduct consistent with previous NPS boatmen who had been disciplined for the same infractions. During this last investigation following the Feb 2014 trip, these 2 women, admitted to the infraction. It was all fair until the disgruntled 13 united and decided to retaliate against the Grand Canyon National Park for infractions from years past that had already been dealt with and apparently not to the 13's satisfaction. The whole thing has hurt the entire community, the Arizona community and the Department of Interior community.  There is no doubt that the way the gonverment deals with these complaints is unsatisfactory to both the complainer and the accused.  At this point, the disgruntled 13's declarations are just alegations as neither side can prove nor disprove other than the 2 WOMEN who's case was admited and proven.  The retalitory smear campaign started after that. 

see more

0    


VGina Wolfe---You are right on. I know these boatmen and have taken many many river trips with them. I was also on the infamous 2014 trip and witnessed first hand what happened. The behavior of these two women was inappropriate, and they were properly disciplined. They were not, as the media says, "fired". They were simply not hired back when their terms ended. There is no black mark on their federal record. The one person still working at the boat shop is bearing the brunt of the accustaions and allegations, even though he has never had a complaint filed against him. It was only after these women perceived that they were wronged did the accusations start coming in. I have know him to be nothing but fair, professional, and helpful on the river. I've witnessed him save lives. This entire debaucle makes me doubt everything I read in the media.


Hmmm - From the last two comments, it would appear there is much more to this story than orignally appeared (as I suspected), yet Rick B. was ready to jump all on board and Lee wanted to blame it on the "conservative entitlement mentality" which he has still not backed up.  Put that down as just another of his long list of baseless accusations.  


I think it's a safe bet that all of these NPS personnel are in the Progressive Entitlement Mentality group. 


"It goes right along with the Conservative Entitlement Mentality which says, "I want services of all kinds, but don't ask me to pay for them."
This is a joke right? You go to the heart of liberal philosophy and attribute it to conservatives?


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.