If a scrawny looking pine tree towered above other pines near Wuksachi Lodge in Sequoia National Park, would you figure out that it was a cellphone tower? And would you then care that your backcountry hikes might be interrupted by someone chatting loudly on their phone or streaming Drake?
Those are questions the National Park Service is seeking your thoughts on as they consider a proposal from Verizon Wireless to disguise a cellphone tower as a pine tree near the lodge.
The ubiquitous nature of cellphones these days brings more and more demands for cell signals wherever one roams, even if they might be in a forest of giant sequoias. That said, just 29 people took time to comment on the proposal earlier this year, though 17 of those expressed concerns that widespread cellphone coverage "reduces the contrast between wilderness and other lands, and negatively impacts wilderness character."
Against that position, though, are the views of employees in the park who feel isolated without cellphone coverage, and the safety aspect of being able to quickly contact help.
A total of 203 health and safety incidences were recorded in the Lodgepole / Wuksachi area in 2017, including search and rescue calls (20), emergency service calls (146), motor vehicle collisions (33), and fatalities (4). -- National Park Service
Verizon Wireless is proposing to construct a 138-foot cellular tower west of Wuksachi Village to achieve a coverage objective that includes a portion of the Generals Highway, the Wuksachi Village, Lodgepole, and Wolverton areas. Antennas would be directed, as much as possible, away from the wilderness, the park's environmental assessment says.
Comments on the plan are being taken through November 26.
The proposed wireless communications facility would include the following components within a 40-foot by 40-foot area adjacent to two existing above-ground water storage tanks:
- A 138-foot tall tower with panel antennas and microwave dishes, potentially constructed to simulate a pine tree, mounted on a 4 to 5-foot diameter footer
- A covered 28-foot by 13-foot steel equipment platform
- A 500-gallon propane tank mounted on a concrete pad
An estimated 1,420 feet of buried electrical cable would be installed along the existing access road to connect the tower to an existing electrical transformer. Two 14-inch diameter fir trees would be removed from the facility site. A total of approximately 0.23 acres of land within the park would be affected by the project, including the trenched area adjacent to the access road (0.19 acres), and the communications facility (0.04 acres).
Comments
We managed to survive up until a couple of decades ago without cell phones...now we have to have them everywhere? Kinda defeats the purpose of getting out in God's nature!
No!!! People go to sequoia national park to unhook from technology. They should be enjoying the beauty around them. They dont Need their face in a phone to distract them further. I understand this could save people but it could also lend to more incidences happening. Texting and driving, people not being aware of their surroundings and getting hurt. My vote is no!!
Horrible idea. In this day and age more than ever people need a place where they can detach from the digital world I'm a former employee of Sequoia National Park, and not having any cellphone coverage for months on end was one of the greatest perks of the job. God forbid it forced people to interact face to face. Regarding emergencies, when a person enters the wilderness they need to do so knowing the risks. The potential to save a life or two is not worth the park selling its soul.