You are here

Study: Loss Of Colorado River Would Cripple Economies Of Seven States, From Wyoming To California

Share
Alternate Text
The summer of 2002 brought record low flows to the Colorado River. This shot of the Big Drop Three rapid in Cataract Canyon in Canyonlands National Park at a flow of 2,700 cubic feet shows how recreation can be impacted by a declining Colorado River. Now Arizona State University economists have put a dollar figure on how a drying up of the river would impact the economies of surrounding states/NPS, Neal Herbert

The prospect of the Colorado River running dry anytime soon is hard to fathom. But if it ever does, it will have a devastating effect on the economies of the seven states that rely on the river's life-giving waters, according to a study prepared by Arizona State University researchers.

"Without the full availability of Colorado River water at current levels, the combined economy of the Basin Region is estimated to fall by over $1.4 trillion," the study's executive summary states. The loss would extend to more than 16 million jobs -- with $800 billion in wages -- in the states of Wyoming, Colorado, Utah, Arizona, New Mexico, Nevada, and southern California, it adds. 

Put another way, the jobs tied to the river that would be lost are equal to 12.2 percent of national private employment.

Since the mid-20th century, intensive water consumption has dried the lower 100 miles of the Colorado River such that it no longer reaches the sea except in years of heavy run-off; and the United States Bureau of Reclamation (USBR) anticipates significant shortfalls between projected water supplies and demands in the Colorado River Basin in the coming decades.

"We've long suspected the impact of the Colorado River to be quite large, but the results of this study help to quantify it,' said ASU economics professor Timothy James, lead author of the study. 'œThe detailed analysis reveals how deeply intertwined the economy of the region is with the river's health."

Worries about the Colorado River's flows and the many demands on it are not new, but stretch back decades, and even more than a century if you consider Major John Wesley Powell's admonition that there simply wasn't enough water to go around in the West. The writer Marc Reisner reiterated the message a bit more vehemently in Cadillac Desert, the American West and its Disappearing Water.

More recently, in 2010, Jonathan Waterman, author of Where Mountains are Nameless, Arctic Crossing, Kayaking the Vermilion Sea, and In the Shadow of Denali, took his best shot to convince local, state, and federal officials -- and all the souls who live from Colorado and Wyoming to southern California -- that there is no possible way the Colorado River can survive, let alone sustain, the demands being made on it. 

In Running Dry, A Journey From Source to Sea Down the Colorado River, Mr. Waterman cast the Colorado as a diseased coronary artery running through the Southwest. He clearly diagnosed the disease by analyzing the math attached to the water that feeds the various watersheds draining into the Colorado, and the over-appropriated demands on them. He talked with the director of the Glen Canyon Dam that reins in the Colorado before it can sweep tumultuously through Grand Canyon National Park, and in doing so contrasted the ongoing stand-off between hydro-generation and the natural ebb and flow of river flows the canyon needs to stay healthy.

The nine units of the National Park System that help define the river basin -- Rocky Mountain, Black Canyon of the Gunnison, Curecanti, Arches, Canyonlands, Dinosaur, Glen Canyon, Lake Mead, and Grand Canyon -- have been sculpted through time by the currents of the Colorado River and its tributaries. 

Today, while the drainage'™s slacking waters might not outwardly impact the appearance of these parks, they impact them just the same. Fisheries suffer from reduced currents and dropping reservoirs. River runners see the Green, Yampa, and Colorado rivers changed by the lower flows. Vegetation and wildlife in the parks that rely on the rivers are impacted.

The very force that has created these national parks and which in many cases defines many of them is substantially at risk. The growing recreational uses, as a consequence are at risk as well.

Now the economics of the river have come to the forefront in The Economic Importance Of The Colorado River To The Basin Region. Authored by Professor James, Dr. Anthony Evans, Eva Madly, and Cary Kelly at Arizona State's L William Seidman Research Institute, W. P. Carey School of Business, the study works to drive home how a drying up of the Colorado River, for practical purposes, would cripple the surrounding states.

* Economy of the West Crucially Dependent on the Colorado River: Nearly 2/3rds of the CO River Basin'™s Economic Value Vanishes if the Colorado River Runs Dry

* $871 billion in labor income could be lost EACH YEAR if Colorado River water was no longer available to businesses, industry and agriculture.

* All business sectors risk economic losses if we further deplete this resource. The five PRIVATE SECTOR industries basin-wide that would decline the most are: 

--Real Estate & Rental ($174.3 billion)

--Healthcare & Social Services ($148.6 billion)

--Finance & Insurance ($137.1 billion)

--Professional, Scientific & Technical Services ($130.6 billion)

--Retail Trade ($96.2 billion)

If there was just a 10 percent drop in the Colorado River's flow, it would cost the seven states $143.4 billion in lost Gross State Product, the authors estimated, 1.6 million jobs, and $87.1 billion in salaries. A 50 percent decline would chop $717.1 billion from GSP, 8 million jobs, and $435.7 in income, they added.

 

Alternate Text

Featured Article

Comments

In the 1800's it was widely believed that "Rain follows the plow."  Now we seem to believe that "Rain follows more and more development."

Will we ever learn that the truth that drives all this is simple.  It's an unshakable belief that Dollars follow more and more development.  But what about the future? 

Some among us care not for the future because it might limit a few of the dollars in our pockets.

It's simply wisdom vs greed.


An  article in today's Las Vegas Sun  asks, "When Will Las Vegas Run Out of Water?" Even if the worst case predictions are wrong, as another recent story points out, Lake Mead doesn't have to dry up entirely to create major economic problems for not only S. Nevada, but parts of Arizona and S. California as well. 

This article from NOAA notes that on July 11, 2014, Lake Mead "reached its lowest water level since the lake was first filled during the construction of the Hoover Dam in the 1930s."

"Runoff in the Upper Colorado River Basin was 94 percent of average in 2014... but only 47 percent of normal in 2013 and 45 percent in 2012, according to the Bureau of Reclamation."

The 2014 National Climate Assessment "also warns that the current drought could be just beginning. Southwest paleoclimate records show that severe mega-droughts at least 50 years long have occurred in the past several thousand years." 

No one can accurately predict what the snowpack in parts of Colorado and Utah (the major source of Colorado River water) will be in coming years, but if the trends for the past 15 years continue, there's cause for serious concern. 


Does anyone know if all the recent rain in that area did anything for Lake Mead?? Did it rise at all?


http://www.arachnoid.com/NaturalResources/

Looks like that rain didn't help much. 


It's all in this book, published already a quarter century ago:

Marc Reisner, Cadillac Desert: The American West and Its Disappearing Water. Still one of the best accounts ever written about how the American West got overbuilt. No surprises here, good people, unless you really believe that water transfers encourage limits to growth. Come to think of it: Is that not what we are being told about "renewable" energy, too? If we can now make the desert into a solar power plant, all of our problems will be over! Once, water flowed uphill toward money; now money is following the sun.

 

 


The "reality" of this situation may well come from Mother Nature rather than politicians, especially if recent trends in the amount of water coming down the river continue. If that's the case, a lot of people will face very difficult situations, and it will be both sad and interesting to see the posturing and finger-pointing that will occur by politicians at many levels. 


I'm afraid you have it right, Jim.  It's gonna be ugly no matter what.  It will be ugliest of all for many people who bought homes there without doing their homework first as well as for people who have lived there all their lives without paying attention to what was happening around them.

But it will be okay.  They can simply blame the President -- whoever he or she happens to be at the time.


Hmmm, could millions upon millions of new residents of the Southwest be a good thing or a bad thing for the Colorado River Basin?  Simple question, I believe.  A conservative asks the question.   What will the reality of all this be if politicians decide?  Do any of you consider the impacts of open borders obviously intended blatently to add voter rolls to the Democratic Party?  Does anyone think it's purely for humanitarian motivations?  Obama, the sensitive Mother Theresa incarnation?  We are doomed if his case carries the day, seriously.  

 


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.