You are here

UPDATE: National Park Staff Furloughed, Park Visitors Largely On Their Own

Share

Rangers were not available Saturday to remove trees downed on the road leading to the Hoh Rain Forest in Olympic National Park, according to NPCA/NPCA photo

Editor's note: This updates with a photo from Olympic National Park of trees down on the road to the Hoh Rain Forest.

As Saturday dawned, the government was shut down, most National Park Service personnel were furloughed, and visitors to the parks were largely on their own. No fees were collected, many restrooms and visitor centers were closed, but concession operations were in business.

Whether any visitors would get into trouble -- a couple at Big South Fork National River and Recreation Area got lost last weekend and stayed out overnight in single-digit weather with the Park Service fully operational -- some groups were voicing concern that Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke's decision to keep the parks open while most Park Service personnel were sent home was dangerous.

While the government was shut down on Saturday, national parks remained open while most National Park Service employees were furloughed.

"There is no substitute for National Park Service staff and their expertise, and it is not wise to put the public or our park resources at risk by allowing for half-measures to keep them open," said Theresa Pierno, president and CEO of the National Parks Conservation Association. "And yet, that’s exactly what the Department of Interior is asking park superintendents to do. Keeping parks open with virtually no staff is a risky situation, and the guidance park staff is being given is vague at best."

At the Sierra Club, Jackie Ostfeld, associate director of the Outdoors Campaign, said,"(T)he reality is that our parks can’t operate without the Park Service. Keeping them open without staff is dangerous for both visitors and for the delicate ecosystems in our parks. Risking both visitors and important cultural sites to win political points is the height of irresponsibility. But it shouldn’t surprise anyone to see this administration put our parks at risk - after all, this is the same administration that wants to double entrance fees and shut out low-income families from our national parks, all while proposing massive budget cuts to the National Park Service.

“Trump may have escaped a few bad headlines today by keeping parks open through this irresponsible and damaging government shutdown, but the millions of people who love and enjoy our national parks every day won’t forget all the damage done to our public lands by this administration.”

Some problems were noticed across the National Park System, where rangers were not immediately available at Olympic National Park to remove trees downed on the road to the Hoh Rain Forest, said representatives of the National Parks Conservation Association.

NPCA staff estimated that "approximately a third of our 417 national park sites are now completely closed, including places like Ford’s Theatre, the Statue of Liberty, presidential homes, and other historic and cultural sites primarily made up of buildings that can be locked. Other park sites will remain semi-open, and what is accessible to the public will differ from park to park."

"More than 21,000 Park Service employees are being furloughed during park closures," noted NPCA's John Garder. "Thousands more contract employees and small business owners will also be affected. That leaves a 3,298 'essential staff' to manage 80 million acres of national park lands, from Acadia to American Samoa to Zion."

Different parks were handling the shut down differently, and with some interesting impacts. At Everglades National Park in Florida, for instance, the fish cleaning station was closed, but the boat launches were open. Backcountry camping was allowed, but on a first-come, first-served basis, and no permits were being issued, which could create some problems.

Opinions on the impact of the shutdown, and who was responsible, ran the gamut on Traveler's Facebook page.

"Who misses rangers when they dress like cops and act like cops? Law enforcement has no place in the parks," wrote Chad Emery.

But Jeff Darren Muse wrote, "Think about more than a snapshot. Whenever you visit a national park — be it one with a natural emphasis, cultural, or otherwise — you visit a place that represents a long history of struggle and success with stewardship. Stewardship for this and future generations — the heart of the Organic Act of 1916. Geologists and biologists and archeologists are part of that history. Firefighters and trail crew and resource specialists are. Law enforcement officers. Emergency responders. Interpretive rangers and educators giving formal programs to families and school groups, or informal activities in visitor centers, at bus stops, near trailheads. Wilderness rangers combing through permits and working to keep the backcountry, well, the backcountry. Maintenance staff!

"This shutdown is a big deal," he went on. "If it’s short, not too big. If it drags on, parks and other public lands will be threatened. The primary threat? Taking them — and their preservation — for granted. You don’t just save a place once. You have to save it over and over and over again. That’s what these employees do. With partners, of course. With the public. For now, get out there, enjoy yourself, please look after the place. No other country in the world has this remarkable heritage."

And Judi Staab pointed out that, "Just remember those of you who disrespect our hard-working rangers, they are also the ones who have to fish your boiled carcass out of the boiling water when you disregard the danger signs in Yellowstone, pick up your mangled body parts when you are in a climbing accident or taunt a bison, and haul you out on a litter from the backcountry. Don't think they're getting paid the big bucks and they are living in substandard park housing with little or no insulation and no a.c.

"Just sayin'! Good luck out there today! Hope you don't need a ranger!"

Traveler footnote: If you're out in the park system during the government shutdown, please share your experience in comments to this story. Did you miss Park Service rangers, did you encounter any issues?

Comments

Yes Kurt, there are SARs in non-NPS lands just as the are in NPS lands.  Heck there have been books written about deaths in the National Parks while well stocked with Rangers.  That is why I said "for the most part".  People will do stupid or dangerous things with or without Rangers.   In my opinion, the lack of paid rangers in the parks is unlikely to have a material impact on visitor safety.



I don't need a Ranger to "hold my hand" in the parks (tho I've seen a few that I wouldn't mind holding hands with). They have often added to my enjoyment of a park as they share tips on neat trails, out-of-the-way spots for good photos, and where the wildlife hot spots are at the moment. And the visitor centers usually have exhibits, books, maps, etc. that add to the experience. That being said, it is still perfectly possible to enjoy a park visit without these extras. And I hope most of us are mature enough to act sensibly and obey the rules even if the ranger isn't on duty. BUT, what I worry about is those among us who do not have any respect for nature or cultural heritage. I remember a man walking out in Harbison Meadows with his toddler son, intent on getting up close to a moose despite a bunch of us along the road yelling at him. Just as the moose started bobbing his head, a ranger drove up and hastily intervened. I worry about idiots who think their initials are as vauable as ancient Native American petroglyphs, or who think pushing over balanced rocks is some kind of fun. Yeah, that happens when the rangers are working, but I suspect the threat of being caught actually does deter at least some of the vandalism and stupidity.


What is apparent are the differences between this shutdown and the last one under Obama.  This one seems to mitigate the difficulties to a degree rather than the previous one making it as difficult as possible.  Is it just me or are there accomodations that were not apparent in Obama's shutdown?


As far as the road debris Im betting 9 out of 10 locals in that neck of the woods would routinely be carrying a chainsaw and have it cut up and loaded in short order.


Trailadvocate:  We actually witnessed that volunteer role at Redwoods N.P. when during windstorms along the Redwood Northcoast,  trees and debris land on the

Highway:  Major Hwy  101;  fortunately,  the trees were small diameters and pickup drivers with chainsaws played a critical role opening the road.

Of course, for SAFETY, best not to travel through forested corridors during windstorms.  During the Columbus Day Windstorm of 1962,  there were several

near vehicle misses along Oregon State Hwy 62 through Rogue River N.F. approaching the west entrance of Crater Lake N.P. and these were large old growth trees.


trailadvocate, I like your respect and appreciation for our nations public lands but my own experience with a  major national park, over 50 years now both as a ranger and now emegency hire fire information officer has been that those who feel they do not need help, are usually the ones we help the most. 


Thankfully this can come to end... who knew, people can handle themselves for a few days!


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.