You are here

Renewed Effort To Build Tramway At Grand Canyon Draws Concern

Share

A proposal to build a hotel development on the rim of the Grand Canyon in the Navajo Nation, with a tram going to the canyon bottom, has resurfaced/River Runners for Wilderness graphic

A renewed effort has been launched within the Navajo Nation to have a tramway built from the rim of the Grand Canyon down to the bottom at the confluence of the Little Colorado and Colorado rivers.

Though Navajo Nation President Russell Begaye said back in May 2015 that his administration opposed the so-called Escalade project, on Monday tribal councilman Ben Bennett introduced legislation to the Tribal Council calling for $65 million to help fund the project, which he portrayed as badly needed economic development for members of the Bodaway/Gap Chapter of the tribe. That money would be spent on building an access road and providing utilities to the tram site.

As Councilman Bennett envisions the project, it would include the tram, a Riverwalk, amphitheater, and food pavilion, all located along the western edge of Navajo Nation lands. There would be a restaurant on the canyon floor and a hotel on the canyon rim, according to Save the Confluence, a Navajo group opposed to the project.

At full development, the legislation states, the project would employ upwards of 1,100 with an "estimated payroll of $28 to $38.5 million." That estimate does not, however, "include employment from the Lease Pads for the hotels, RV-park, or convenience store, which are anticipated to generate another 1,300 jobs."

Grand Canyon National Park officials had no comment Tuesday, saying they were reviewing the legislation and what it calls for. At the National Parks Conservation Association, though, Kevin Dahl expressed concern over the re-emergence of the project.

"It is no surprise that the Scottsdale developer who envisions great profit from constructing a huge resort hotel and tramway on this beautiful and remote rim of the Grand Canyon is trying again to get the Navajo Tribal Council to literally buy in to his scheme, despite having been turned down before and despite opposition from the current Navajo administration," Mr. Dahl, NPCA's Arizona program manager, said in an email. "NPCA has grave concerns that if this plan goes forward there will be huge environmental impacts, such as damage to Blue Spring from pumping groundwater and disposing sewage. The spring is the perennial source of water for the Little Colorado River and the only remaining breeding habitat for an endangered fish, the Humpback Chub. The resort would bring noise and light pollution to one of the most isolated and pristine parts of the canyon.

"While we acknowledge the Navajo Nation’s sovereignty over development on their own lands," he continued, "we also strongly urge that the tribal council look at this very closely to decide if this is best for the Navajo people. We ask that they support local Navajo residents’ opposition and respect the agreements they have made with other tribes to protect each other’s sacred sites. The Hopi and Zuni were quick to ask the Navajo not to do this when it was proposed in the past, and nothing has changed."

The legislation calls for Confluence Partners, LLC, a Scottsdale, Arizona-based concern, to handle development and operations. Opponents say Confluence would receive 88-92 percent of the generated revenues, and that the company has no experience with construction projects. According to the legislation, the Navajo Nation would received a franchise fee of 8-18 percent of gross revenues "based on various visitor attendance levels."

The legislation further points out that while the Navajo Nation and Grand Canyon National Park share a common border, and that while the National Park Service has expressed concern about the project and its impact on the canyon, "the federal government, through the Navajo Nation Trust Land Leasing Act of 2000, has authority to conduct business site leasing without subsequent federal approval and the Escalade project environmental review will comply with Navajo laws..."

In 2015, American Rivers listed the Colorado River in the Grand Canyon as America’s Most Endangered River because of a battery of threats surrounding the Grand Canyon. One of these threats was the proposed Grand Canyon Escalade project, which "would create a massive development and tramway with noise, trash, and pollution scarring the heart of the canyon," the group said.

Comments

Hell no! That would devistate the conyon !


Pleasr stop this from happening !!


You forgot a couple, folks.

"Nothing dollarable is safe, however guarded." John Muir

"Money is patient." Michael Frome

As for Native Americans "loving" the land, I hate to disappoint anyone with history, but natives are people, too. Beginning in the 1600s, they were willing participants in the fur trade, for example, in the hopes of bettering their lives and prospects. Who wouldn't have done the same? We must look at this, as the late Carsten Lien reminded us, "in the cold, hard light of day." Congress may need to step in and condemn this property--just as eminent domain has been used for other parks. The Navajo would get a perpetual tax payment, perhaps, but not the "right" to develop Grand Canyon.

After all, if indeed they love the canyon more--and money less--there should not be any problem. They can take our money instead of the developer's money, and yes, save Grand Canyon for every citizen of the world. However, asking anyone, including Native Americans, to resist development while their economy suffers, is virtually to ask the impossible. Just read the actual history, not the politically-correct history, of the past 400 years.


just say no...protect the land


we can see the Grand Canyon as nature presented it.  Greedy people want to come in and exploit what God so freely gave us. NO, NO! no to this development.

 

 


Where's the Monkey Wrench Gang when you need them...


Leave the Canyon as is!


Of course, another point to consider is what the "original" developers did to Grand Canyon--and other major national parks. A century ago, it was proposed that a cable car span the entire canyon, linking both the North and South rims. That didn't happen, but a sprawling infrastructure did. If we're so concerned about this latest development, what do we propose doing about the historical one? Do we really need an airport at South Rim, for example? And what about the massive wind farm, midway between South Rim and Williams, entirely visible from North Rim?

Certainly, we can't just be taking it out on the Navajo--or any of the other tribes. If we want a wilderness Grand Canyon, let's make all of it wilderness--including the part "we" compromised, yes? Leave El Tovar, Hopi House, Kolb Studio, VerKamps, and Canyon Depot--and tear down all the rest. Leave Grand Canyon Lodge at North Rim.

Funny, but when the Grand Canyon Railway itself proposed that 20 years ago, the Park Service didn't want to go there--and declared all of its "architecture" historical. No wonder developers keep seeing an opening. The "preservationist" on site still wants the automobile, which is how every mess in the parks has mushroomed. 


Add comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.