You are here

Nearly Two Dozen National Parks Ban Sales Of Disposable Plastic Water Bottles

Share
Alternate Text
More and more parks are installing water-filling stations, such as this one at Arches National Park/Kurt Repanshek

Nearly two dozen units of the National Park System have instituted bans against the sale of disposable water bottles, a move proponents say will greatly reduce trash.

For most parks, according to Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, disposable plastic water bottles represent the biggest source of trash that parks must pay to haul away, averaging nearly one-third of all solid waste in parks surveyed.

"Ending sales of plastic bottles in national parks has gotten off to a slow start due to the influence of Coca-Cola, whose Dasani bottled water is one of the top sellers, on top National Park Service officials," PEER maintains. "In 2010, just days before a long-planned plastic bottle ban at Grand Canyon National Park was to take effect, NPS Director Jon Jarvis blocked it at the company's behest. Even more significantly, NPS abandoned its plan to end disposable water product sales in 75 percent of all visitor facilities by 2016."

However, after the matter gained public attention the Park Service director relented, though he issued a directive that required parks to extensively study the impacts of instituting such a ban before they would be permitted to do so. 

The analysis required elaborate assessments that included a review of the amount of waste that could be eliminated from the park; the costs of installing and maintaining water filling stations for visitors; the resulting impact on concessionaire and cooperative association revenues, and consultation with the Park Service's Public Health Office.

The analysis also dictated the consideration of "contractual implications" to concessionaires, the cost and availability of BPA-free reusable containers, and signage so visitors could find water filling stations.

Perhaps due to the controversy, only a handful of national parks adopted bans under the new policy in 2012, its first full year. In 2013, records obtained by PEER indicate that no park that sought a bottle sale ban was turned down and another six parks went bottle-free:

* Colorado National Monument;
* In Texas, Pecos and San Antonio Missions national historic parks;
* In North Carolina, the Outer Banks Group; and
* In Utah, Natural Bridges and Hovenweep national monuments.

Beyond the 23 parks in 10 states that already do not sell plastic water bottles, California'™s Golden Gate National Recreational Area, the most heavily visited national park, and Florida'™s Biscayne Bay National Park, are both installing water 'œfilling stations' to provide free water to visitors. In addition, Washington'€™s Mount Rainier National Park indicates it is working on a ban, according to PEER.

"€œFrom desert to ocean parks, from remote wilderness to urban enclaves, the drive to remove the blanket of discarded plastic bottles appears to be slowly regaining momentum,"€ said PEER Executive Director Jeff Ruch, noting that NPS replaced its goal of a ban on bottle sales at 75 percent of facilities with a vaguer target that parks cut solid waste streams by half by 2016, the year of the NPS Centennial.

"National Parks will be hard pressed to meet the goal of cutting their expensive and un-ecological solid waste load by half without addressing plastic bottles --€“ the single largest source of trash in most parks," said Mr. Ruch.

Word that nearly two dozen parks had banned the sale of the plastic bottle was praised by Corporate Accountability International, which long has lobbied for the ban.

"€œWe applaud the more than 20 national parks that have ended the sale of bottled water on park lands, taking a critical step towards reducing waste and standing up as leaders within the park service by protecting water as a public good," said Erin Diaz, director of the Think Outside the Bottle campaign at the organization.

'With the support of our members, allies, and hundreds of small businesses, organizations and park partners, Corporate Accountability International is calling on the the National Park Service to end the sale of bottled water."

Comments

Lee, it was at Point Reyes National Seashore.

/2011/03/these-ingenious-meta-bottles-carry-important-message-point-reyes-national-seashore7838


ec's responses and credibility are simply pathetic. But expected. It's obvious that trolling others into endlessly twisting arguments in Traveler is some kind of hobby for ec.

But for those whose minds are not clamped shut, here is a link to another Waste Management Company info sheet about recycling plastics.

http://www.wm.com/thinkgreen/what-can-i-recycle.jsp

The last two paragraphs in this informative piece are particularly interesting: "It takes more than 1.5 million barrels of oil to produce a year's supply of water bottles. That's enough oil to fuel 100,000 cars for a year.

Some plastics cannot easily be made into other products, or doing so is not economically feasible. If your local recycler doesn't accept a particular type of plastic, it's probably because the market for that resin is small or non-existent."

Management of our trash and garbage stream is one of the most expensive and most difficult challenges faced by local governments in this country. A large part of the challenge is trying to deal effectively with a strong lobby of manufacturers of such things as plastic bottles and grocery bags.

It reminds me of a comment made by a man from Germany I met in Zion many years ago. When I asked what surprised him the most about America, he replied, "The size of your garbage cans!"


There are a lot of areas to improve in this. In our little town plastics cannot be recycled - they go to the incinerator. Along with trying to reduce the amount we use, we take our recycle along 100 miles up into the Yukon to a town that does recycle plastic. I'm actually heading out to go there in a couple of minutes. The gas in the car would already be spent as this is an every-couple-month shopping trip.

Less plastic used, better access to proper recycling - every little bit helps. I realized years ago that you can't "save the world" - it just pisses off the world; witness EC's little tantrums. I just try to improve what I can, when I can. Using refillable water bottles helps this.


It takes more than 1.5 million barrels of oil to produce a year's supply of water bottles. That's enough oil to fuel 100,000 cars for a year.

So what?

Management of our trash and garbage stream is one of the most expensive and most difficult challenges faced by local governments in this country

.

Well then lets ban the sale of newspapers and magazines, books and paper cups and anything else made with paper. Paper accounts for 30-40% of the landfill tonnage versus 5% or so for plastic bottles (of all kinds)


Documentation, please, ec.


So? All any of that proves is that we need better recycling programs and much more strict requirements that everyone must use them or face severe penalties. Paper decomposes. Most plastic doesn't.


Paper decomposes. Most plastic doesn't.

Little decomposes in a landfill. One study found meat still on chicken bones 15 years after disposal. Whether it does decompose or not doesn't really make a difference. A landfill is capped, re-purposed and what happens under ground is irrelevant.

But your stance really highlights your hypocrisy. Paper is 6-10x the impact on a landfill yet you aren't clamoring to ban paper from the parks. Why? Perhaps the issue (for you) isn't what goes in a landfill. Lets be honest. What is your "agenda"?


The Essential RVing Guide

The Essential RVing Guide to the National Parks

The National Parks RVing Guide, aka the Essential RVing Guide To The National Parks, is the definitive guide for RVers seeking information on campgrounds in the National Park System where they can park their rigs. It's available for free for both iPhones and Android models.

This app is packed with RVing specific details on more than 250 campgrounds in more than 70 parks.

You'll also find stories about RVing in the parks, some tips if you've just recently turned into an RVer, and some planning suggestions. A bonus that wasn't in the previous eBook or PDF versions of this guide are feeds of Traveler content: you'll find our latest stories as well as our most recent podcasts just a click away.

So whether you have an iPhone or an Android, download this app and start exploring the campgrounds in the National Park System where you can park your rig.